Craving a slice of mouth-watering pizza in Sarasota? Look no further! This article will guide you on an epic pizza journey, revealing the hottest spots that serve up the most delectable pies in the city. From crispy thin crusts to gooey cheese and an array of tantalizing toppings, get ready to satisfy your pizza cravings like never before. So grab a napkin and prepare to drool as we uncover the hidden gems where you can find the best pizza in Sarasota.
1. Downtown Sarasota
When it comes to finding delicious pizza in Downtown Sarasota, you won’t be disappointed. You have a variety of options to choose from, each offering their own unique flavors and styles. Let’s explore some of the top spots in this vibrant area.
1.1 Il Panificio
Il Panificio is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Downtown Sarasota. This cozy pizzeria is known for its authentic Italian flavors and traditional Neapolitan-style pizzas. The dough is made fresh daily, and the toppings are carefully selected to create a perfect balance of flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Margherita or a gourmet pie with prosciutto and arugula, Il Panificio is sure to satisfy your cravings.
1.2 Mozzarella Fella
If you’re looking for a slice of New York in Sarasota, look no further than Mozzarella Fella. This family-owned and operated pizzeria prides itself on serving up authentic New York-style pizzas that are packed with flavor. From the crispy thin crust to the gooey, melted cheese, every bite is a delightful experience. The menu also features a variety of toppings to choose from, allowing you to create your perfect pizza masterpiece.
1.3 Simon’s Coffee House
While Simon’s Coffee House may be known for its delicious coffee and cozy ambiance, their pizza deserves a shoutout as well. Their wood-fired pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection. The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are always generous and flavorful. It’s the perfect spot to grab a slice and relax with a cup of coffee after a day of exploring Downtown Sarasota.
2. Siesta Key
If you find yourself on Siesta Key, you’re in for a treat. This beachside paradise offers not only stunning views but also some fantastic pizza options. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Siesta Key has something for everyone.
2.1 Sol’s NYC Pizza
Sol’s NYC Pizza is a Siesta Key favorite when it comes to satisfying pizza cravings. The pizzeria specializes in large, foldable New York-style slices that are perfect for a quick bite on the go. The dough is thin and chewy, and the toppings are plentiful. Whether you choose a classic cheese slice or opt for one of their specialty pies, Sol’s NYC Pizza will transport you to the streets of New York with every bite.
2.2 Anna’s Deli
Anna’s Deli has been a beloved establishment on Siesta Key for over 30 years, and their pizza is not to be missed. The deli offers a unique twist on traditional pizza by offering a variety of specialty options, such as their famous Reuben pizza. The crust is fluffy and light, and the toppings are creative and delicious. It’s the perfect spot to grab a slice and enjoy the laid-back atmosphere of Siesta Key.
2.3 City Pizza
City Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria that has been serving the Siesta Key community for over a decade. Their menu features a variety of specialty pizzas, including their popular BBQ Chicken Pizza and Veggie Delight. Each pizza is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, and the flavors are unparalleled. Whether you dine in or take your pizza to-go, City Pizza promises a memorable dining experience.
3. Gulf Gate
Gulf Gate is a neighborhood in Sarasota that is often overlooked but is home to some fantastic pizza joints. If you’re in the area, be sure to check out these hidden gems for a slice of pizza heaven.
3.1 Rick’s Risotto Pizza
Rick’s Risotto Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts in Gulf Gate. This unique pizzeria combines the flavors of Italy by topping their thin-crust pizzas with creamy risotto. The result is a delightful combination of textures and flavors that will leave you craving more. With options like their Truffled Mushroom Risotto Pizza or their classic Margherita with Risotto, Rick’s Risotto Pizza offers a unique twist on traditional pizza.
3.2 Razza Pizza Artigianale
Razza Pizza Artigianale is a charming Italian pizzeria tucked away in Gulf Gate. They specialize in crafting authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas that are made with imported Italian flour and San Marzano tomatoes. Each pizza is cooked in a wood-fired oven, resulting in a perfectly charred crust that is both crispy and chewy. With their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and traditional techniques, Razza Pizza Artigianale is a local favorite for pizza connoisseurs.
3.3 Sam Snead’s Oak Grill and Tavern
If you’re looking for a little more than just pizza, Sam Snead’s Oak Grill and Tavern is the place to go. This upscale restaurant in Gulf Gate not only offers delicious wood-fired pizzas but also a range of other delectable dishes. Their pizzas feature creative topping combinations, such as the Prosciutto and Fig Pizza or the BBQ Chicken Pizza. With its cozy atmosphere and mouthwatering menu, Sam Snead’s Oak Grill and Tavern is a perfect spot for a special night out.
4. Southside Village
Southside Village is a charming neighborhood in Sarasota that is brimming with culinary delights, including some top-notch pizza places. Whether you’re looking to dine in or grab a slice to-go, Southside Village has you covered.
4.1 Sam’s Woodfired Pizza
Sam’s Woodfired Pizza is a local favorite in Southside Village, and for good reason. This cozy pizzeria offers a wide variety of pizzas, all cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven. From classic favorites like Margherita and Pepperoni to unique creations like the Sweet Heat with jalapeños and honey, Sam’s Woodfired Pizza has something for everyone. The crust is thin and slightly charred, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. It’s the perfect spot to gather with friends and enjoy a delicious meal.
4.2 Lolita Tartine
Lolita Tartine is a hidden gem in Southside Village that specializes in gourmet pizzas. Their menu features a mix of classic and inventive combinations, all made with high-quality ingredients. From their Truffle Pizza with mushrooms and truffle oil to their Fig and Goat Cheese Pizza with arugula, every slice is a burst of flavors. The crust is thin and crispy, providing the perfect base for the delicious toppings. Whether you’re a pizza purist or love to experiment with unique flavors, Lolita Tartine is a must-visit in Southside Village.
4.3 Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery
For those craving a taste of the Windy City, Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery delivers authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizza right in Southside Village. Each pizza is a hearty masterpiece, with a thick buttery crust, layers of gooey cheese, and your choice of delicious toppings. Whether you opt for the classic Cheese Deep Dish or venture into their specialty pizzas like the Meat Lover’s or Spinach and Feta, Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery is a slice of Chicago heaven in sunny Sarasota.
5. University Park
Located near the University Park area, these pizza joints cater to the hungry student population as well as locals and visitors. Whether you’re in the mood for classic pizza or want to try a unique twist, University Park has some excellent options to satisfy your cravings.
5.1 Old School Pizza
As the name suggests, Old School Pizza is all about preserving the traditional flavors and techniques of pizza-making. Their hand-tossed pizzas are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and baked in a brick oven for that perfect crispy crust. The menu offers a range of classic options, such as the Pepperoni or Margherita, as well as specialty pizzas like the Philly Cheesesteak or Buffalo Chicken. With its friendly atmosphere and mouthwatering pies, Old School Pizza is a hit among the University Park community.
5.2 Chicago’s Best Burgers and Pizza
If you’re a fan of both burgers and pizza, then Chicago’s Best Burgers and Pizza is the place for you. This University Park eatery serves up mouthwatering deep-dish pizzas that are packed with flavor. Each pizza is loaded with your choice of toppings, and the crust is thick and buttery. Pair your pizza with one of their juicy burgers, and you have the perfect indulgent meal. With its welcoming ambiance and flavorful menu, Chicago’s Best Burgers and Pizza is a great spot for a hearty pizza feast.
Napolitano’s is a family-owned pizzeria that has been delighting the University Park community for over a decade. Known for their authentic Italian flavors and generous portions, Napolitano’s never disappoints. Their pizzas are made with love and care, using only the freshest ingredients. From their classic Margherita to their indulgent Quattro Formaggi, each bite is a taste of Italy. Whether you’re dining in or ordering takeout, Napolitano’s ensures a satisfying pizza experience every time.
Just a short drive from Sarasota, Bradenton offers its own array of fantastic pizza options. From cozy pizzerias to upscale restaurants, Bradenton has something for every pizza lover.
6.1 Fire and Stone
Fire and Stone is a hidden gem in Bradenton that should not be missed by pizza enthusiasts. This cozy pizzeria offers a variety of unique and inventive pizzas that are made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The crust is thin and crispy, providing the perfect base for the delicious toppings. From their savory Truffle Pizza to their indulgent Lobster Pizza, Fire and Stone pushes the boundaries of traditional pizza and delivers a truly memorable dining experience.
If you’re looking for a taste of authentic Italian pizza, head over to Vesuvio’s in Bradenton. This family-owned restaurant takes pride in their traditional Neapolitan-style pizzas, which are cooked in a wood-fired oven for an authentic flavor and texture. The crust is soft and chewy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. Whether you choose a classic Margherita or one of their specialty pizzas, Vesuvio’s guarantees a taste of Italy in every bite.
Ortygia is an upscale Italian restaurant in Bradenton that offers a refined dining experience along with delicious pizza. Their wood-fired pizzas are made with high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection. From the Nduja with spicy sausage to the Tartufo with black truffle and pancetta, each pizza is a fusion of traditional Italian flavors and innovative combinations. With its elegant ambiance and impeccable service, Ortygia is the perfect spot for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.
7. Lakewood Ranch
Lakewood Ranch is a vibrant community in Sarasota that boasts a variety of dining options, including some fantastic pizza joints. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual slice or a gourmet pizza, Lakewood Ranch has something for everyone.
7.1 Mr. Beery’s
While Mr. Beery’s is primarily known for its extensive craft beer selection, their pizza offerings are not to be underestimated. This casual eatery serves up delicious wood-fired pizzas that are perfect for pairing with your favorite brew. The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. Whether you’re a fan of classic Margherita or prefer something more adventurous like their Bacon and Blue Cheese pizza, Mr. Beery’s has a pizza to satisfy every palate.
7.2 Apollonia Grill
Apollonia Grill is a Mediterranean restaurant in Lakewood Ranch that also crafts some incredible pizzas. Their menu features a variety of specialty pizzas that combine the flavors of Greece and Italy. From the Margherita Mediterranea with feta cheese to the Bianco Gyro with gyro meat and tzatziki sauce, Apollonia Grill’s pizzas are a fusion of traditional and innovative flavors. With its warm ambiance and friendly service, Apollonia Grill is a fantastic spot to enjoy a delicious meal with family and friends.
7.3 Linger Lodge Restaurant
For a unique dining experience in Lakewood Ranch, head over to Linger Lodge Restaurant. This rustic eatery is located on the banks of the Braden River and offers a quirky and charming atmosphere. While they are known for their alligator dishes, their pizza should not be overlooked. Each pie is made with their signature homemade crust and loaded with a variety of tasty toppings. Enjoy your pizza while taking in the serene natural surroundings, and you’ll have a dining experience to remember.
8. St. Armands Circle
St. Armands Circle is a vibrant shopping and dining destination in Sarasota that is known for its upscale establishments. If you’re in the mood for gourmet pizza and a touch of elegance, St. Armands Circle has some fantastic options to choose from.
8.1 Café L’Europe
Café L’Europe is an iconic fine dining restaurant in St. Armands Circle that offers a diverse menu of European-inspired dishes. While they are widely known for their elegant ambiance and impeccable service, their pizza offerings are equally impressive. Their wood-fired pizzas are made with artisanal ingredients and cooked to perfection. From the classic Margherita to the decadent Lobster Pizza, Café L’Europe’s pizzas are a true culinary delight. Indulge in a slice or two while enjoying the sophisticated atmosphere of St. Armands Circle.
8.2 Columbia Restaurant
If you’re looking to experience the flavors of Cuba in addition to fantastic pizza, Columbia Restaurant is the place to go. This family-owned establishment has been a landmark in St. Armands Circle for over a century and is known for its authentic Spanish and Cuban cuisine. While their menu features a variety of traditional dishes, their Pizzeta Española stands out. This unique pizza is topped with chorizo, manchego cheese, roasted red peppers, and cilantro, creating a mouthwatering fusion of flavors. Enjoy a slice of this Spanish delight while taking in the lively atmosphere of St. Armands Circle.
8.3 Venezia Restaurant
Venezia Restaurant is a charming Italian eatery in the heart of St. Armands Circle that offers a cozy ambiance and delicious food. Their pizza menu boasts a variety of traditional and gourmet options, all made with their signature homemade dough and fresh ingredients. From the classic Margherita to the Prosciutto e Rucola topped with prosciutto and arugula, Venezia Restaurant’s pizzas are a treat for the taste buds. Pair your pizza with a glass of wine from their extensive selection, and you have the perfect recipe for a memorable dining experience.
Venice is a picturesque coastal town near Sarasota that offers not only stunning beaches but also some incredible pizza options. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, these pizza joints in Venice are worth a visit.
Borruso’s is a local favorite in Venice when it comes to delicious pizza. This family-run pizzeria specializes in New York-style pies that are packed with flavor. The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are piled high. From the classic Cheese or Pepperoni to the specialty Greek Pizza with feta and black olives, Borruso’s offers a wide range of options to satisfy every palate. Whether you dine in or take your pizza to-go, Borruso’s promises a satisfying and flavorful experience.
9.2 Vinnie’s Pizzeria
Vinnie’s Pizzeria is a charming neighborhood pizzeria in Venice that has been serving up delicious pies for over a decade. Their menu features a range of classic options, including the ever-popular Meat Lover’s and Cheese Pizza. Each pizza is made with premium ingredients and baked to perfection, resulting in a delightful combination of flavors. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or a whole pie to share, Vinnie’s Pizzeria is a fantastic choice for a satisfying pizza experience.
9.3 Bella Luna Cafe
Bella Luna Cafe is a cozy Italian eatery in Venice that offers a warm and inviting atmosphere along with delicious pizza. Their menu features a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas, all made with fresh ingredients and homemade dough. From the classic Margherita to the unique Chicken Alfredo Pizza, each slice is a burst of flavors. Add a glass of wine from their impressive selection, and you have the perfect recipe for a memorable dining experience at Bella Luna Cafe.
10. North Port
Last but not least, North Port offers its own excellent pizza scene just waiting to be explored. Whether you’re a resident or a visitor, these pizza places in North Port are worth checking out.
Paparelli’s is a beloved pizzeria in North Port that serves up some of the best pizza in town. Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection in a stone oven, resulting in a crispy yet chewy crust. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Margherita or an adventurous BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch, Paparelli’s has something for every pizza lover. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere add to the overall dining experience, making it a must-visit in North Port.
10.2 Michael’s Pizzeria and Pasta
Michael’s Pizzeria and Pasta is a family-owned and operated restaurant in North Port that offers classic Italian cuisine, including delicious pizzas. Their menu features a range of traditional and specialty pizzas, all made with authentic recipes and high-quality ingredients. From the classic Cheese and Pepperoni to the gourmet Four Cheese Bianca or the hearty Meat Lovers, Michael’s Pizzeria and Pasta has a pizza to satisfy every craving. Dine in or order takeout, and you’ll be treated to a flavorful and satisfying meal.
10.3 Solorzano Bros. Pizza
Solorzano Bros. Pizza is a popular pizza joint in North Port that has been serving up delicious pies for over 25 years. Their pizzas are made with fresh dough, homemade sauce, and a blend of premium cheeses, resulting in a perfect harmony of flavors. The menu offers a variety of options, from classic favorites to specialty creations like the Buffalo Chicken or the Hawaiian BBQ Chicken. Whether you prefer thin crust or deep-dish, Solorzano Bros. Pizza has got you covered. Head over to this North Port gem and indulge in a slice of pizza heaven.
In conclusion, Sarasota and its surrounding areas are a pizza lover’s paradise. From the bustling streets of Downtown Sarasota to the charming neighborhoods of Siesta Key, Gulf Gate, Southside Village, University Park, Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, St. Armands Circle, Venice, and North Port, there are countless pizza joints waiting to satisfy your cravings. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or want to explore unique and inventive creations, Sarasota has something for everyone. So, grab a friend, hop in the car, and embark on a pizza adventure through the beautiful and tasty Sarasota.